CONTACT US

For any general inquiries, please fill in the following contact form:

Our websites never use cookies or other technologies such as pixel tags and web beacons. We only retain personal information when the contact section of our websites is filled. To proceed and get in touch with us through this format please read our Terms & Conditions, updated to be in line with the provisions of the GDPR, and tick this box to consent in us retaining the above information for contacting purposes only.

SUBMIT

Tobacco firm BAT ‘costs developing countries $700m in tax’

Tobacco firm BAT ‘costs developing countries $700m in tax’

Campaigners say company uses ‘financial manoeuvring’ to shift profits to tax havens

British American Tobacco has been accused of depriving developing countries of hundreds of millions of dollars in tax by using “financial manoeuvring” to shift profits to a UK subsidiary.

The Tax Justice Network estimated that London-based BAT, the world’s largest tobacco company, would avoid paying $700m (£540m) between now and 2030 in Bangladesh, Indonesia, Kenya, Guyana, Brazil, and Trinidad and Tobago.

It said that in 2016 alone BAT managed to shift $941m, roughly 12% of its group pre-tax profit that year, from overseas companies into its British subsidiary, BAT Holdings.

This, it said, reduced the company’s tax bill, partly because UK corporation tax is charged at 19% – lower than many of the countries in which BAT sells cigarettes.

There is no suggestion that any of the methods allegedly used are illegal and BAT said it complied in full with tax legislation in the countries where it operates.

But in a detailed report entitled Ashes to Ashes, the Tax Justice Network said BAT’s practices “fly in the face of tobacco companies’ claims to be essential tax providers to low and middle income countries where 80% of the 1.1bn smokers worldwide live”.

The campaign group’s chief executive, Alex Cobham, said: “Cigarettes not only impose massive human costs, those who profit from them are actively depriving lower-income countries of the public funding they need to provide people with health services.

“At a minimum, governments must require tobacco companies to publish country by country reporting to make sure profits are taxed in the communities where they were raised, not in the tax havens they were siphoned off to.”

The organisation said BAT had managed to shift profits from developing countries to its UK subsidiary, which pays relatively little corporation tax using a variety of methods.

They include arrangements where an overseas company pays royalties to the UK business, and charging foreign subsidiaries interest fees on loans, some routed through low-tax areas such as the Netherlands.

The Tax Justice Network said the picture was incomplete because BAT had more than 100 offshore subsidiaries in 19 tax havens where financial data is opaque, while the company’s accounts also revealed hundreds of millions of dollars paid in unexplained “other operating charges”.

Its 62-page report broke down its method of calculating BAT’s alleged “financial manoeuvring” in several countries.

In Bangladesh, for instance, it said BAT’s outpost there declared $21m in obligations owed to British subsidiaries between 2014 and 2016, in royalties, technical and advisory fees and IT charges.

The payments meant that, rather than paying tax on those profits at local rates, the company paid a much lower “withholding tax rate” set by a bilateral treaty between the UK and Bangladesh.

It said this cost Bangladesh $5.8m in lost tax in 2016, enough to cover the country’s health expenditure for more than 200,000 people for a year.

The annual economic cost of tobacco consumption in Bangladesh, where 40% of men over 15 smoke daily, is $1.8bn and smoking causes more than 25% of deaths among men, according to tobaccoatlas.org.

A spokesman for BAT said it “does not accept that there is any avoidance or loss of tax to the countries concerned in the manner contended by the report.

“The group fully complies with all applicable tax legislation where it does business, operates the transactions that occur between group companies on an arm’s length basis [at market rates] and is a significant tax contributor to governments worldwide.

“Classifying countries such as the Netherlands and the UK as tax havens is simply not a credible claim … the tax loss of $58.2m [per year until 2030] identified by the report simply does not arise.”

It said the tax losses claimed by Tax Justice Network did not arise because services provided by UK companies to overseas subsidiaries incurred genuine costs.

BAT also told the Tax Justice Network that transactions between group companies were subject to frequent external scrutiny.

Source: https://www.theguardian.com

MORE NEWS

Tax authorities mount raids on 19 German banks and homes

Tax authorities mount raids on 19 German banks and homes
Tax authorities mount raids on 19 German banks and homes.  Investigation is linked to Panama Papers and part of money laundering ...

Subpoenas issued for six years of Donald Trump tax returns

Subpoenas issued for six years of Donald Trump tax returns
The chairman of a US Congressional committee has issued subpoenas for President Donald Trump's tax returns. Richard Neal said in a ...

Calls for mandatory tax on gambling industry to treat addiction in UK

Calls for mandatory tax on gambling industry to treat addiction in UK
Overhaul of laws needed, with onus on industry to reduce problem gambling, says BMJ paperGambling laws should be radically overhauled, ...

Who's behind the blog

Who's behind the blog

SOCIAL MEDIA